The 5-Flavor Fix: How to Troubleshoot and Balance Any Dish
Once you master these five tastes, you gain the power to troubleshoot any dish that seems “off” and to layer flavors for incredible depth, all without a recipe. According to science, there are five basic flavors: salty, sweet, sour, bitter, and umami (umami is taken from the Japanese word for delicious because it was discovered by a Japanese researcher umami is a “savory” or “meaty” flavor). This is important in cooking without a recipe because in learning anything new mistakes are inevitable and most kitchen troubleshooting uses opposing flavors to balance a dish that isn’t quite right.
The universal fixes
Oh no, you just added too much (fill in the blank)! Don’t panic, there are several fixes:
- Increase volume: Make more of the recipe without adding any more of the offending flavor
- Dilute: Add more liquid (water, stock, etc.)
- Absorb & add bulk: Add more plain ingredients such as:
- Fats, help coat the tongue and can counter sour in a dish
- Starches: potatoes, rice, noodles
- Beans
- Veggies, or fruit (depending on what you’re making)
Balancing opposing flavors
You can also balance the flavor of something by adding one or more of its opposing flavors. Usually flavors have more than one opposite, this gives you options and more control over the flavor of your dish.
Salty
Pro tip: Even seasoned chefs occasionally over or under salt things. Just remember to add any salty ingredients like soy sauce or cheese before salting and always taste before and after you salt!
Opposing Flavors:
- Sweet
- Sour
Examples:
Usually salt is just salt, but remember that soy sauce (or liquid aminos), cheese, and olives can all add to the saltiness of a dish. Also beware of condiments and seasoning blends containing salt.
Sweet
Pro tip: Many people only use sweet when they want a dessert. However, sweet can round out a dish, softening other flavors making them “blend” better. If your dish tastes “fragmented” with the saltiness, sourness, and herbs all feeling separate, add something sweet and it doesn’t have to be sugar. For example use sautéed carrots to round out tomato sauce.
Opposing Flavors:
- Salty
- Sour
- Bitter
- Umami
Examples:
Sugar, molasses, brown sugar, honey, maple syrup, agave syrup, fruit, fruit syrup, carob, carrots, sweet potatoes, beets, butternut squash and pumpkin.
Sour
Pro tip: Sour is an amazing flavor fixer, it can balance any other flavor. If a dish is too fatty or just feels “flat,” add an acid. A little sour goes a long way.
Opposing Flavors:
- Sweet
- Bitter
- Salty
- Umami
Examples:
Vinegar, lemon or lime juice, yogurt, sauerkraut and fermented foods, sour cream, pickles, rhubarb, sour cherries, and sourdough
Bitter
Why use Bitter? If a dish is heavy on fat or sugar, it can feel too rich to keep eating. Bitterness cuts through that richness and cleanses your taste buds, making every bite taste fresh. It adds the “bass notes” that turn a flat dish into a complex one.
Opposing Flavors:
- Sweet
- Salty
- Sour
- Umami
Examples:
Brewers yeast, herbs, ginger, walnuts, cocoa, coffee, chicory, citrus, and vanilla extract or other extracts
Umami
About
Umami is sometimes referred to as savory, but it is more of a “deep pleasant savory” sometimes described as a “meaty” flavor. It was first discovered while studying the amino acid glutamate. However, since then two other molecules have been found to trigger those tastebuds.
When you combine different types of umami they work together and multiply that deep savory taste many times over. Also cooking, roasting, or drying umami ingredients usually intensifies their umami.
For example, while raw onions are sharp, the heat of cooking triggers the Maillard reaction. This transforms the onion’s sugars and proteins into deep, savory compounds creating that umami satisfaction.
Opposing Flavors:
- Sour
- Sweet
- Bitter
Examples:
Glutamates (The Foundation)
Best for all-around savory base.
Soy sauce / Liquid aminos, tomatoes especially sun dried, miso paste, garlic and cooked onions
Inosinates (The Meatiness)
Best for deep, hearty “meaty” notes.
Meat broths and stocks, parmesan cheese, nutritional yeast, fish, and meats (even greater amount in cured meats)
Guanylates (The Earthiness)
Best for earthy, lingering depth.
Mushrooms fresh or dried, seaweed, green peas, and corn
Umami & layering create depth
Ever wondered what people mean by saying something has good “depth” of flavor? It usually means that the dish has some umami and also some complexity in it. This complexity comes from layering ingredients from the different flavor groups.
“Ye are the salt of the earth: but if the salt have lost his savour, wherewith shall it be salted? it is thenceforth good for nothing, but to be cast out, and to be trodden under foot of men.”
Matthew 5:13
For further reading:
If you want to know more about umami in plant based cooking? This article from Forks over Knives is really informative.
Umami at Home: 12 Umami Power-Ups for Big Flavor – Offcuts Kitchen talks about the power of Umami synergy.
